Unpopular opinion: I used to think Red Velvet was overrated. Cue the gasps, the clutching of pearls, the "HOW DARE YOU?!" But hear me out.

Red isn’t a flavour. Neither is velvet. Last time I checked, licking a crimson velvet sofa just tastes like regret. The name alone is enough to confuse—what exactly are we eating? A colour? A texture? And yet, Red Velvet continues to have a cult following, inspiring cakes, cupcakes, lattes, Oreos, and even perfumes. (Yes, someone thought frosting-scented eau de toilette was a good idea.)

But despite my long-standing RedXit, I have to admit that Red Velvet deserves more respect than I once gave it. Because done properly, it's more than just a cake—it’s a piece of baking history.

Red Velvet’s Origins – A Story of Chemistry and Clever Marketing

Unlike my assumption that Red Velvet was just a glorified vanilla sponge dyed red, it turns out it has deep roots in 19th-century American baking. The term velvet originally referred to cakes with a fine, tender crumb. Bakers discovered that combining cocoa, buttermilk, and vinegar created a natural chemical reaction that enhanced the cake’s softness and gave it a subtle reddish-brown hue.

But here’s where things get interesting—the colour wasn’t always bright red. The original Red Velvet cakes were closer to burgundy because they relied on unprocessed cocoa reacting with acidic ingredients. The fire-engine red we see today? That’s thanks to food colouring.

The Rise of Red Velvet – From Hollywood to Cupcake Obsession

The cake gained real fame in the 1920s, when the posh pastry chefs at the Waldorf Astoria Hotel in New York added it to their signature desserts. Then, in the 1930s, the Adams Extract Company decided to sell more red food dye by publishing a recipe that made the sponge even redder than before. It worked. The cake became a hit, and Red Velvet as we know it was born.

Fast forward to the 1980s, and Red Velvet got a pop culture boost from Steel Magnolias (yes, that armadillo cake). Then, in the 2000s, Sex & the City made cupcakes trendy, and suddenly Red Velvet cupcakes were everywhere. The cake’s explosion in popularity led to an over-saturation—it was no longer a special treat but a default bakery menu item.

The Fall of Red Velvet (And Why It’s Making a Comeback)

I’ll admit it—I rebelled against Red Velvet. I turned my nose up at it, convinced it was all hype and no substance. But here’s the thing: Red Velvet isn’t the problem. Bad Red Velvet is.

A proper Red Velvet cake isn’t just a chocolate cake dyed red. It’s a delicate balance of flavours—subtly cocoa-scented, slightly tangy from the buttermilk, and not too sweet. The texture is soft, plush, and melt-in-the-mouth.

And let’s talk frosting. Today, most people assume cream cheese frosting is the traditional pairing—but originally, Red Velvet was topped with ermine icing (also known as boiled milk frosting). Made from a roux of flour, sugar, and milk whipped into butter, it’s lighter, silkier, and far less sweet than typical buttercream. I’d argue it’s the best way to finish a Red Velvet cake.

Red Velvet Today: Love it or Rebel Against it?

Like a zombie trend that refuses to die, Red Velvet still reigns. Case in point: our latest Red Velvet cake giveaway had 200+ entries. Apparently, people still want their cake… and to smell like it too.

Lots of Red Velvet love,

Reshmi xoxo

View our Red Velvet Cakes